When AI Becomes Elegant

My younger brother Karl sent me a text yesterday.

That alone isn’t particularly unusual, but what he sent was. Karl is a police captain, a pretty stoic guy, and not someone who spends a lot of time sharing his feelings or philosophical observations.

It was a link to an episode of The Daily, titled When A.I. Comes for Your Purpose in Life.

Coming from Karl, I figured this must be important.

So Sherry and I sat at the dining room table, eating stuffed peppers I’d made for dinner, and hit play.

The guest was Steven Strogatz, a mathematician at Cornell, talking about something I hadn’t given nearly enough thought to.

Artificial intelligence is beginning to solve some of the hardest mathematical problems in existence. Problems that brilliant people have spent their entire careers trying to solve. Problems that young mathematicians dream of tackling someday, hoping to make their mark on the world.

There’s a hero’s journey in mathematics. You dedicate your life to understanding something nobody else has figured out, and maybe, just maybe, you’re the one who cracks it.

AI is starting to take that journey away.

And it’s not just solving these problems through brute force.

It’s solving them elegantly.

That word stopped me.

Elegance

Years ago at HookLogic, our CTO, Kevin Hermida, wrote a function to generate a GUID, a globally unique identifier.

Nothing revolutionary about that. It’s a problem thousands of engineers had solved thousands of times. There was already a widely accepted approach.

But Kevin’s implementation was different.

I can’t tell you the exact details of that function today, but I can still remember appreciating what he’d done. It wasn’t just that the code worked. It was the way he’d thought about the problem.

It was beautiful in its simplicity.

Elegant.

Years later, at Amazon, that word came up again.

Amazon is an extraordinarily data-driven company. How do you objectively measure the performance of a software engineer?

You can count code commits. Look at defects that escape into production. Measure reliability, delivery, operational performance, and the quality of technical decisions.

But somewhere among all those things that can be measured is something much harder to quantify.

Elegance.

I knew exactly what that meant because I’d seen Kevin’s function.

But how do you measure it? How do you explain to someone that two engineers can solve the same problem, produce the same result, and one solution can somehow be vastly more beautiful than the other?

Sometimes you just know it when you see it.

Back at our dining room table, Strogatz explained that AI had solved a difficult mathematical problem by connecting two fields of mathematics that hadn’t traditionally been considered together.

Discrete geometry and number theory.

The information already existed. The mathematics already existed. But nobody had thought to connect those particular dots in quite that way.

AI did.

And the mathematicians thought the solution was beautiful.

Elegant.

That’s a pretty remarkable moment in human history.

What Happens to Purpose?

I’ve known plenty of PhDs throughout my career. Most tend to be pretty reserved about their emotions. Not unlike Karl.

But here was one of the world’s most accomplished mathematicians, struggling to hold back tears on a podcast.

He wasn’t simply worried about losing his job.

He was confronting the possibility that human beings might soon no longer be the smartest things on this planet.

And perhaps more painfully, that the thing he’d dedicated his life to, the joy of discovering something nobody else knew, might be something a machine could do better.

There’s a Japanese concept called ikigai, roughly translated as your reason for being. There’s a wonderful book by that name that explores finding meaning and purpose in the things we do.

This book hit home for me, and I shared it with my son, to help him understand why. The answer for me is him.

What happens when the thing that gives your life purpose can be done better by something that isn’t alive?

That’s a much more troubling question than whether AI will take your job.

And I don’t have an answer.

I Think There’s a Limit. Maybe.

I’ve been working with AI professionally for years. I’ve consulted on it, studied it, read some of the papers, and lately I’ve spent an almost ridiculous amount of time building things with it.

In the last two weeks alone, I’ve rebuilt a spinning wheel application and started making software for a 40-year-old Timex Sinclair 1000.

Things I wouldn’t have imagined doing this quickly a few years ago.

But I’ve never built a large language model from scratch. My understanding of how they work comes mostly from the outside.

And that leaves me with a theory I’m not entirely sure I believe anymore.

Large language models learn from enormous quantities of information. Human knowledge, published research, code, books, conversations, and countless other sources.

More information than any human could consume in a thousand lifetimes.

But it’s still information that already existed in some form.

I’ve generally believed that this creates a fundamental limitation. AI can predict, combine, reorganize, and find patterns in what humanity has already created. But genuinely new ideas? I’ve tended to believe those still have to come from us.

Then I think about that mathematical proof.

Two fields of mathematics. All the information sitting there for years. Nobody connected them.

Until AI did.

Was that a new idea?

If it was new to every mathematician on Earth, and it solved a problem nobody else could solve, does it really matter that the underlying knowledge already existed?

I don’t know.

Maybe the distinction I’ve been relying on isn’t much of a distinction at all.

That’s an uncomfortable thought.

A Conversation at Work

The next day, I shared the podcast with some colleagues.

We work with AI all day, every day. The company has always moved at an insane pace, and now we’re doing things even faster.

But one of my favorite parts of work isn’t the technology.

It’s the people.

We have fantastic banter. Some of us have worked together for years. Others I’ve only recently met. We don’t agree on much of anything, and we’re perfectly willing to tell each other why, and the other truly listens.

Some of us, admittedly, are a little chattier than others.

I love those days. I need that connection with other people. The arguments, the jokes, the occasional moment when somebody says something that changes how you see the world.

We talked about the podcast, about AI, about what it can do today, and what it might eventually become.

After plenty of debate, I posed something that was almost a rhetorical question.

Today, when we want to know something, we ask AI.

It can teach us almost anything. Explain quantum physics. Help us understand a medical diagnosis. Teach us a new language. Or show an enthusiastic amateur how to vibe code a video game for a computer that was obsolete before most of today’s engineers were born.

Now imagine ten years from now.

What if AI is solving problems we can’t even begin to imagine today?

What if it discovers cures for cancer or diabetes, diseases affecting millions of Americans?

Or multiple sclerosis and pulmonary fibrosis, diseases that affect fewer people but can be absolutely devastating to the people living with them and the families who love them?

These aren’t just interesting technical challenges.

They’re things people have spent their entire lives hoping someone, somewhere, would figure out.

What if AI does?

Would anyone care whether the solution was elegant?

Would the scientists who’d dedicated their lives to those discoveries feel the same loss of purpose that Strogatz described?

Or would the joy of seeing people get better outweigh everything else?

I suspect both could be true.

At work we talk a lot about how two truths can be held at the same time.

Maybe Thit Will Need Us

And this brings me back to the question I posed at work.

What if there really is a limit to what AI can figure out from everything humanity has already learned?

Maybe that limit is much further away than I thought. Maybe it doesn’t exist in the way I imagined.

But the world is bigger than our collective published knowledge.

There are experiences that haven’t happened yet. Questions nobody has thought to ask. Observations nobody has written down. Connections waiting to be made.

Perhaps the next great breakthrough won’t come from AI knowing more than we do.

Perhaps it will come from a person seeing something in the world that nobody, human or machine, has ever noticed.

A mathematician. A physician. An engineer. A teacher. Someone tinkering in their basement.

Someone with an unusual perspective, a little curiosity, and an idea that seems completely ridiculous until it works.

And maybe, instead of us asking AI to solve every problem, there will come a day when AI needs something from us.

A missing observation. A question it hasn’t considered. A connection it couldn’t make on its own.

Imagine that.

The most powerful intelligence humanity has ever created, asking a human being for help.

Maybe it will be you.

And maybe, together, you’ll come up with something elegant.

Thit Happens

The AI Pronoun Debate Nobody Asked Us to Settle

A long time ago, in the Amazon Detroit kitchen, next to the nitro cold brew keg, I had a surprisingly serious conversation with Bernard “GBones” Grunow about a question the world had not yet realized it needed answered.

A quick aside about the coffee. It was from Hyperion Coffee, and their nitro cold brew is absolutely REDONKULOUS and super high in caffeine, which may explain what happened next.

Bernard has an English degree from the University of Michigan. I’m pretty good at writing, but my understanding of the technical aspects of English is somewhere between questionable and nonexistent.

So naturally, we felt uniquely qualified to tackle the obvious question:

What should the pronouns for AI be?

To be clear, this wasn’t a conversation about human gender or identity. We were wrestling with a grammatical question about artificial intelligence. As AI becomes increasingly conversational, helpful, and occasionally infuriating, how should we refer to these things?

“He” or “she” seemed unnecessarily human. “It” seemed a little impersonal for something that might eventually do most of our work. “They” already had plenty of responsibilities.

Of course, the sensible answer would have been to keep using “it” and “they.” But sensible answers rarely survive excessive quantities of nitro cold brew.

After unnecessary debate, way too much caffeine, and absolutely no formal authority, GBones decreed the correct answer:

  • Singular: thit
  • Plural: thits

A few examples to demonstrate the elegance of our contribution to the English language:

“Thit finished my work before I even opened the laptop.”

“Thits may soon decide who is ‘Top Tier’ and who is ‘Least Effective’ at OLR.”

For those unfamiliar with Amazon’s employee review process, just know that the second example is either a promising efficiency improvement or a terrifying glimpse into the future.

At the time, this was mostly an exercise in caffeinated absurdity. But as AI systems become more capable, the question gets a little more interesting.

We naturally give personalities to things we interact with. We name our cars, yell at our computers, and thank Alexa for turning off the lights. AI makes that instinct even stronger because it can carry on a conversation.

That doesn’t make AI human. In fact, having language that distinguishes artificial intelligence from human intelligence might become increasingly useful as the line between what humans do and what machines can accomplish gets blurrier.

And I’ve recently realized GBones and I left a glaring hole in our new grammatical framework.

What happens when a human and AI work together?

“We” doesn’t quite capture it. After all, one of us is human, and the other is a collection of algorithms with an alarming capacity for agreeing with me.

Clearly, we need another pronoun.

Thwe.

Thwe = me + AI working together!

As in:

“Thwe built an another entire project this week.”

“Thwe may have created more bugs than thwe fixed.”

It’s an important distinction. “Thits” refers to multiple AIs. “Thwe” describes a collaboration between humans and AI.

And frankly, with the amount of work I’m doing alongside AI these days, I find myself needing “thwe” a lot more often than I expected.

Of course, there’s an alternate school of thought. If you know your AI well enough, perhaps pronouns become unnecessary and you simply address thit by name.

Mine is Atlas.

And lately, thwe have been getting quite a bit done.

I’m sure the English language will survive our contributions. Probably.

When Changing Your Mind Feels Like Surrender

For 29 years after World War II ended, Hiroo Onoda kept fighting.

I recently listened to Werner Herzog’s The Twilight World on the Libby app (free with your local library card), and I loved both his writing style and his narration. Herzog has a way of making the story feel almost mythical without losing the strange, uncomfortable truth beneath it.

Hidden deep in the jungle on the remote Philippine island of Lubang, Onoda survived through extraordinary discipline, resourcefulness, and an almost unimaginable commitment to his final military orders to continue guerrilla resistance, never surrender, and never take his own life until he was formally relieved by a superior officer. Leaflets announcing Japan’s surrender didn’t convince him. Current newspapers didn’t convince him. Even messages and photographs from his own family were dismissed as enemy propaganda designed to trick him into surrendering.

One of Herzog’s strangest examples captures just how far that suspicion could go. Onoda and his men find a piece of chewing gum stuck beneath a bridge rail and wonder whether an American soldier left it there, or whether it was deliberately planted to mislead them. They leave it untouched. Months later, they return and Onoda is certain the gum has moved slightly. That tiny change triggers an entire spiral of suspicion: Had one of his own men secretly chewed it? Was it poisoned or drugged? Was someone lying? Something as mundane as a piece of old chewing gum becomes another piece of evidence in a war that exists largely because every piece of evidence can be made to fit it.

His greatest strength had become his trap.

Onoda’s story feels uncomfortably relevant to America today.

We increasingly live inside our own versions of the jungle; political, cultural, and algorithmic echo chambers where loyalty to the narrative becomes more important than evidence that contradicts it. New information isn’t simply wrong. It becomes suspicious. The people presenting it aren’t mistaken. They’re part of the trick.

And once you reach that point, changing your mind starts to feel like surrendering to the enemy.

That may be the most interesting lesson from Onoda’s story. Grit, discipline, conviction, and loyalty are usually virtues. But disconnected from the ability to reconsider what we believe, those same virtues can keep us fighting long after the war is over.

Sometimes the hardest form of courage isn’t holding your position.

It’s walking out of the jungle.

(The idea and final editing are me, AI helped write the middle)

Chicago Hot BBQ

Dear Potbelly Sandwich Works test kitchen,

I recently binge read Samin Nosrat‘s cookbook “Salt Fat Acid Heat” and it explained cooking the way my brain works, by starting with “why.” When I was a kid, I didn’t ask why five times to get to root cause; I asked thirty-seven times until my curiosity was completely exhausted — my poor mother!

A couple weeks ago I stopped into Potbelly and ordered my usual skinny roast beef on white with “hot peppers” AKA giardiniera. While waiting, I noticed the Sweet Heat Pork BBQ on the menu, and something clicked.

Salt, fat, acid, heat. Got it. But what about spice?

Capsaicin, the compound that makes hot peppers hot, is fat-soluble. So I started wondering: would adding giardiniera during the cooking process, infuse that signature spicy pepper flavor into the protein itself? So I bought a jar of your Hot Peppers and ran the experiment by making “Chicago Hot” BBQ pulled pork in my Instant Pot.

The result surprised even me. After 60 minutes under high pressure, the pork was fall-apart tender and the giardiniera spice infused directly into the meat, creating a heat that builds and lingers, balanced by sweet BBQ sauce and wet slaw.

Please give my recipe (https://chicagohotbbq.com/) a try and consider adding a “Chicago Hot” BBQ Pulled Pork sandwich to your menu.

P.s. my photography skills lag my curiosity. Who is Skeeter? Well that is a good conversation over a beer :P

Change Password, Feel Better

Change Password to a Daily AffirmationI like to delegate. It’s fun. So today, I am assigning you a task. Don’t worry, it will take less than two minute to complete, so don’t bother writing it down. Just do it.

TASK – Change your computer password into a positive daily affirmation.

Instead of using gibberish passwords like l33tsp3@k or deceased pet names, use a positive affirmation or goal to reinforce good behavior. Simple.

Read more of this post